Opinion · Packaging and selling

Packaging That Has to Work as a Thumbnail Too

Daniel Hauser
· 4 min read
Packaging That Has to Work as a Thumbnail Too

Packaging is designed for the shelf. That is how it is taught and how it is presented: a visualisation in the aisle, lighting, neighbours left and right. Except most people today see that packaging first somewhere else. As a square the width of a finger in a comparison listing, next to twenty others, on white, without any context at all.

±200 pxwidth of a listing thumbnail
1image the decision is made on
0how much of the touch survives a photo

The shelf moved, the design did not

Comparison engines have been the first contact with a brand for a long time. This year two things were added: Heureka released a browser extension that compares prices directly on top of someone else's online shop, and Seznam launched shopping with an agent on Zboží.cz that picks items and fills the cart. In both cases there is one more layer between your packaging and the customer, a layer that reads data and shows a thumbnail.

It does not mean the shelf is over. It means a design that works only in print and only close up is a design for a minority of situations.

What survives being shrunk

  • The silhouette. You recognise the shape of a bottle or a tub before anything on the label. It is the one thing competitors cannot copy quickly.
  • One dominant element. An illustration, a colour or a mark. Two of them merge at small size and neither is left.
  • Colour coding across flavours. In a listing it is often the only thing that says this is a range and not a set of unrelated products.
  • A short name at a usable size. Not the whole claim, not the weight, not every certification.

What is lost

Everything that goes through the hand and through light. Embossing, spot varnish, the texture of the paper, registration, matt against gloss. A photograph does not carry it across, and a thumbnail two centimetres wide certainly does not.

That is awkward mainly because those are exactly what one of the two directions we wrote about in Handmade vs AI-Perfect bets on. Tactile minimalism is excellent in the hand and weak in a thumbnail. That is not a reason not to do it, but it is a decision made deliberately rather than by accident.

Packaging has to win twice. Once as a square and once in the hand. Most designs only deal with the second.

The viewer is also a machine

In a comparison listing it is not only how the packaging looks that decides, but whether the data gets there at all. The main image, the title, the category and the identifier come from the product feed, and when something is missing or does not match, the product fails to join the catalogue and appears nowhere, however good the packaging is.

That is no longer a designer's job, but it belongs in the same conversation. To see what a feed is missing, the free feed check at aitoolkit.cz goes through it, and what breaks in it during expansion or a shop migration is covered in this article.

A test that takes two minutes

  • Shrink the design to two centimetres wide and put it next to five competitors from the same category.
  • Cover the name. Can you still tell it is your brand?
  • Look at it on a phone, not on a monitor. Listings are read there.
  • Try the same in greyscale. If it does not work without colour, the whole design rests on one thing.
Bramko vegetable packaging
Bramko: the shape of the pack and one dominant element work at small size too, because they carry the recognition on their own.

What this means for a brief

Tell the studio where the product will be sold before anything is drawn. Packaging for your own shop with large photographs and packaging that has to succeed in a listing next to twenty others are not the same thing. The two can be reconciled, but that is a decision at the start, not an adjustment at the end.

And ask to see the design shrunk. A lit visualisation in the aisle is lovely and tells you little about how it will actually go.

Have a similar project?

Write a few lines about what you need. I will get back to you personally.

Discuss a project

More articles

Rebon: a brand for a product the customer does not understand

Rebon: a brand for a product the customer does not understand

How to design a brand and a store for domestic water filtration so a layperson grasps what they are buying. From the logotype through product visuals to the design of the whole site.

A website that AI can read: what it means for design and build

A website that AI can read: what it means for design and build

A good-looking page can reach a machine empty. Four design decisions that cause it, and why none of this means building boring websites.

Google will take your videos itself. The brand stops deciding what represents it

Google will take your videos itself. The brand stops deciding what represents it

Since 23 October, Performance Max can pull up to ten videos from your social accounts and site into your ads. This is not an ad setting, it is a question of running a brand.

A Brand That Can Take Several Markets

A Brand That Can Take Several Markets

In an expansion the brand usually breaks before the campaigns do. What has to stay the same in every country, what has to bend, and why it is decided at the first pack rather than at the fifth market.

Handmade vs AI-Perfect: Why Imperfection Is Coming Back

Handmade vs AI-Perfect: Why Imperfection Is Coming Back

When anyone can generate a smooth visual, smoothness stops meaning care. What that does to brands, where we let AI into our work and where a hand still touches paper.

Small Studio or Big Agency? What You're Really Paying For

Small Studio or Big Agency? What You're Really Paying For

Why one experienced person with modern tools and a network of specialists often delivers more than a big agency, and why clients keep returning for years.

How AI Speeds Up Our Work (and Where We Don't Let It Decide)

How AI Speeds Up Our Work (and Where We Don't Let It Decide)

This site was built in eight languages in two days. Here is how our studio works with AI agents, what we built around them, and why humans make every call.

AXA Racing: Three Brands, One Website, a Custom Platform in Days

AXA Racing: Three Brands, One Website, a Custom Platform in Days

How we merged data from Polaris, CFMOTO and GOES into one dealer website with its own admin. Built on Next.js, first version live in three days.